Tammy Tinnerello

Tammy Tinnerello

Final Offer Certified

Realtor ®

Tammy Tinnerello
  • M
Old Lyme
103 Halls Road
P.O. Box 489
Old Lyme, CT 06371

Years in Business

Overall Sales Volume

Properties Sold

About Me About Me

Luxury Real Estate Advisor | Coastal Connecticut

Tammy Tinnerello is a trusted luxury real estate advisor known for her market intelligence, refined aesthetic, and deeply rooted expertise along Connecticut’s shoreline. Representing the Sotheby’s International Realty brand, Tammy delivers a highly personalized, strategic approach to buying and selling exceptional properties, with a focus on coastal and lifestyle-driven markets.

With an in-depth understanding that real estate is both a financial investment and a lifestyle decision, Tammy provides her clients with thoughtful guidance grounded in data, local insight, and long-term value. Her ability to interpret market trends, position properties effectively, and advocate skillfully on behalf of her clients has earned her a reputation for professionalism, discretion, and results.

Tammy’s full-service approach to selling homes extends far beyond traditional marketing. She is known for advising on strategic enhancements, staging, and presentation to elevate a property’s appeal, often helping homes achieve stronger pricing and faster sales. From sophisticated advertising and targeted exposure to contract negotiation, inspection management, and seamless closings, Tammy oversees every detail with precision and care.

For buyers, Tammy serves as a trusted advisor, helping clients navigate competitive markets with confidence. She takes the time to understand lifestyle priorities, architectural preferences, and neighborhood nuances—ensuring each purchase aligns with both immediate enjoyment and future value.

Recognized for her polished brand presence, design sensibility, and commitment to excellence, Tammy Tinnerello offers her clients not only expert representation, but a concierge-level experience defined by integrity, insight, and elevated service.

READ MORELESS
  • Born In Westerly, Rhode Island
  • Lives In Old Lyme, CT
  • Favorite Movie Breakfast at Tiffanys,The Shawshank Redemption,The Godfather (parts 1, 2 and 3!)
  • Passion Real Estate, Front Doors,Cooking Italian food,and HGTV
  • Interests Football, The Islands, Bird Watching, Pickleball, Cooking, Golfing
  • Favorite Lyric Lovely Day - Bill Withers "When I wake up in the morning..."
  • Inspiration My 4 beautiful children!
  • Can't Live Without Anything with Blueberries
READ MORELESS
159 River Rd. Essex

3 White Farm La.

My Awards

  • #7 in Dollar Volume, Company-Wide, 2024
  • #3 in Units, Company-Wide, 2024
  • #3 Dollar Volume, #4 Sold units Company-Wide
  • Diamond Award, 2020, 2021, 2022,2023, 2024
  • Circle of Excellence First and Second Quarters of 2021, 2022
  • #1 in Dollar Volume and Units, Old Lyme Brokerage, 2021, 2022,2023, 2024

My Specialties

  • Member of The Institute For Luxury Home Marketing
Tammy Tinnerello photo 1
Tammy Tinnerello photo 2
Tammy Tinnerello photo 3
Tammy Tinnerello photo 4
Tammy Tinnerello photo 5
Tammy Tinnerello photo 6
Tammy Tinnerello photo 7
Tammy Tinnerello photo 8
Tammy Tinnerello photo 9

My Listings and Sales

Loading listings...

Testimonials (34)

Tammy’s knowledge and expertise was integral in the sale of my home, after trying and failing in a previous engagement. She has a wonderful network that she leveraged to best market my vintage home in a tough Market. Robert Korpak
We simply cannot express how grateful and appreciative we are to have had Tammy Tinnerello as our listing and buying agent. She was professional and engaged throughout the entire process. When issues arose, she was always accessible. We would highly recommend this seasoned professional and would never use anyone else. Thank you Tammy for making selling and buying a new home a memorable and enjoyable experience! Fondly, Kim & Ken Bartlett Kimberly & Kenneth Bartlett
My son did research on who would be the best agent to sell my house and Tammy was the one we picked. I couldn’t be happier with our choice. Thank you Tammy for all your hard work. Diane Bailey
I had a truly exceptional experience working with Tammy to sell my home in Waterford—especially during what turned out to be a challenging moment in the market. I met with three other realtors before choosing Tammy, and I never once second-guessed my decision. From start to finish, she made me feel supported, informed, and genuinely cared for. Tammy consistently went above and beyond—bringing fresh flowers for showings, adding thoughtful touches for the open house, and always showing up with warmth and professionalism. She’s not only personable and easy to work with, but also sharp, strategic, and deeply knowledgeable about the local market. I wholeheartedly recommend Tammy to anyone looking for a realtor they can truly trust, and I would gladly work with her again on either the buying or selling side of a future transaction. Thank you, Tammy! Willa Kammerer Willa Kammerer
Tammy Tinnerello helped me in a very professional manner. Everything was smooth sailing, selling my home in Chester and buying a home in Old Lyme. I will surely recommend William Pitt / Julia B Fee Sotheby's to my friends and family . Thank you . UMA Uma Rao
xxx Ernesto & Kathleen Canalis
Excellent agent who works through impediments while maintaining a professional demeanor. I would highly recommend Tammy Tinnerello as a Realtor. Raymond S. King Executor
Searching for a new home on the Connecticut shoreline we fell in love with the town of Old Lyme. Tammy’s intimate knowledge of the community helped us to quickly find the ideal home for our needs in a difficult market. She was wonderful to work with. Gerlinde Berger-Walliser
The experience was seamless, start to finish! Tammy is great to work with, and understood exactly what we were looking for. Highly recommend! Lisa Diamond & Larry Wasser
Tammy is ABSOLUTELY THE BEST!!! Her dedication and work ethic for her clients is to be commended. She goes ABOVE AND BEYOND her scope of responsibilities as a realtor! She made the transaction of selling our estate smooth and seamless during our most difficult time! THANK YOU FOR BEING YOU TAMMY!!! You were truly a blessing to work with!!!!! Troy Peters
Tammy was very helpful throughout our home buying experience and was able to work to make sure we were getting the best value possible. Her experience was evident and we were glad to be able to work with her. Joshua and Kimberly Ballestrini
Tammy was exceptional and with her enthusiasm and guidance selling our home was a seamless process. Very grateful for her help. Highly recommend. Michael Michelsen Paula L. Halloran
Tammy Tinnerello is the only RA agent we work with in CT. Thank you! Schramma Properties LLC, Edgar Schramma
Tammy T helped ensure our first home purchase went as smooth as possible; she made great recommendations, was an excellent communicator, and everything was completed very quickly. Thanks to Tammy we are in a wonderful new home! Michael and Deanna Gabiga
Tammy is extremely dedicated , knowledgable, and a wonderful to work with as a real estate agent. Attorney Francis Sablone Landing LLC
Tammy Tinnerello has her client’s best interest at heart. She knows the real estate market inside and out and will give you excellent advice. Whether you’re buying or selling, she listens to you and gets you through to a successful conclusion. Susan Zilke
I had a great experience and felt like Tammy, my realtor, was looking out for me! She was honest, dependable, and always answered my questions. David Philip martel and Stacey Beth Martel
Fantastic, it's a pleasure. Old Lyme CT Properties Corp
Team Tammy was amazing and they handled every challenge along the way with enthusiasm and professionalism. From the consideration and planning on how to properly bring the house to market through show casing the house and handling prospective buyers, and ultimately through negotiations of a successful sale, we could not have been more pleased. Richard E Shriver
Knowledgeable and very responsive ... Fran Sablone
Tammy is outstanding! I couldn't have been happier with her helping me find a home. It took awhile and she was always positive and encouraging. I will recommend her to all my friends in the market. Michael Francis Soriano
Tammy Tinnerell was v professional and understood what we were looking for. She kept us informed, and so when the house came back on the market, she immediately informed us. Paula M Goldsmith and Jonathan P Brecht
Tammy was a fantastic advisor to our family during our home buying experience. She was thoughtful, patient, knowledgeable and brought the right level of intensity to ensure our needs were met. We thoroughly endorse William Pitt / Tammy. Nathaniel P & Carolyn Walsh Stone
I've enjoyed all the transactions Tammy has helped us with over the past 2 years. Schramma Properties, LLC
Tammy was right there all through the process. We really enjoyed working with her. She explained things carefully and was always available to answer questions. James C and Madelynn D Zwernrmann
Tammy T and those who filled in as needed (Chrissy and Tony) were excellent. Caren B and Laurence Peters
very professional with Kindness and respect Frama Realty Corp or its assignee
Working with Tammy Tinnerello was simply a pleasure. From the start, she was so helpful and positive. She brought her energy and enthusiasm to work every day. At in every juncture during the selling process, she was there to guide us through it. Her advertising of our property was spectacular. Any questions or issues that arose were quickly answered and resolved. Tammy was personable and professional and took the time throughout the whole to be truly present. We would highly recommend hiring Tammy as your agent! Thank You Tammy! Greg and Kathy Hancock Kathleen P Hancock
Tammy is a fantastic agent. It's a good feeling to know that she always has our best interests in mind. We completely trust her advice and judgement. Lori A. Strobel
Tammy Tinnerello was an amazing agent to work with. She understood our needs from the beginning to the end of the process. Sheryl and Greg Shyloski
Tammy Tinnerello is an excellent agent. She spent the time needed to make the right decisions on real estate purchases. Tammy has my loyalty for all future business. Edgar Schramma Edgar Schramma
Tammy is both an excellent realtor and a kind and patient person. It was a pleasure working with her. Kathy Ridgway, Arthur Pomerante
Tammy was great and helped us thru what proved to be a challenging final few days leading up to the purchase. She was very engaged and really went above and beyond for us. Benjamin A and Meghan M Merris
Tammy did an awesome job!! James Montana

My Communities

Additional Communities

COMMUNITIES
LISTINGS
East Lyme
100
Chester
14
COMMUNITIES
LISTINGS
Deep River
27

Tammy Tinnerello in the News

Connecticut Cottages & Gardens

Deeds&Don’ts…

New Haven Register

Essex home on Connecticut River with floating dock listed for $5.2M…

The Day

Friends & Neighbors: Old Lyme real estate agent earns honor…

i95

Look inside the Connecticut Estate of the Legendary Sergio Franchi…

The Day

The Perfect Pantry…

Inman

Leading in Luxury Roundtable: How can brokerages create an anti-burnout culture…

Contact Me

  • Tammy Tinnerello

    Tammy Tinnerello

    Realtor ®
    M
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

  • Contact