Mary Black Flaherty

Mary is incredible! So lucky to have found her Hans Reuter

Working with Mary was an exceptional experience. She helped us navigate the Rye market for over two years and was incredibly patient, knowledgeable, and supportive throughout the entire process. She was with us every step of the way, always providing honest guidance, answering our questions, and advocating for us. Thanks to her expertise and dedication, we found our home. We couldn’t recommend her more highly! Mario and Ixel Montanini

Besides finding our dream home, working with Mary was the best parts of our home-buying journey. She really listened to what we wanted—even when we weren’t totally sure ourselves—and somehow showed us exactly what we needed without ever pushing us beyond our limits. She came to every showing fully prepared, thoughtful, and with an eye for things we would’ve completely missed. More than anything, she brought care, honesty, and a calm confidence that made the whole process feel possible, up until the final walkthrough. She helped us go from not knowing where in Westchester we wanted to be, to finding a home we truly love—one we didn’t even think we could have. Mary became a trusted voice—and a friend— and we’re so grateful for her. We couldn’t recommend her more, she made what could’ve been a stressful search feel exciting, supported, and deeply personal. Sara, Testimonial Request

Mary did a wonderful job for us. Thank you for all your assistance with our purchase. Lawrence S. and Elizabeth T. Mazzeo

Mary is an incredible realtor and a true gem. She has been by our side throughout the entire process of selling our home and navigating the journey of buying a new one, making what could have been overwhelming feel seamless and even enjoyable. When it came to selling, Mary’s expertise and strategy were unmatched. She helped us stage the house, coordinate two open houses, and navigate multiple bids, ultimately selling our home in just two days for the price we wanted. She also has an extensive network of trusted professionals—contractors, photographer, and handymen—who helped us make key improvements to get the house market-ready. Her deep knowledge of the Rye real estate market was invaluable—she knows this area inside and out and guided us every step of the way. As we continue our journey of buying a new home, Mary has been just as amazing. She has helped us navigate a challenging and competitive market, always coming prepared with solutions and a thoughtful approach. She is incredibly patient, kind, and proactive, ensuring we stay informed and confident in our decisions. Beyond her professionalism, Mary’s positive attitude has made all the difference. She remains optimistic and encouraging no matter the challenge, always focused on finding the best outcome for us. Above all, Mary has become a friend, and we couldn’t recommend her more highly. If you’re looking for someone who is knowledgeable, strategic, well-connected, positive, and truly invested in her clients’ success, Mary is everything you could ask for in a realtor! Ixel and Mario Montanini

Mary was always there to support us and offer guidance from start to finish. We felt that she understood our wants and needs which enabled us make a house purchase decision after years of looking with someone else. She took the stress away from us, because we knew she was double checking. Lastly, she had good vendor recommendations and was easy to be around. All things needed in this easily stressful process! Jon and Rachel Spice

She was lovely. Hope to work with her again! -Karl Karl Smarsch , Buyer!

Mary quickly found me an exceptional apartment that met all of my search criteria. I’m so happy with my new home. Julia

Mary was positively incredible. Not only was she an amazing broker but she truly became a friend. She thought of everything and ensured that we were taken care of throughout the entire process. I always felt as if Mary was looking out for our family. She connected us with local experts and was always available for any question or concern that we had. We cannot recommend her enough. She is an expert in the market. I will be sure to refer all of our family / friends to Mary. We would love to work with Mary again! Colin and Ali Winrow

Mary was fabulous in every way!! She is thoughtful, responsive, honest and a pleasure to work with. My son and I worked with Mary on finding a rental in Westchester and, although we ended up choosing another location, she was gracious and always helpful. I would definitely call upon Mary again if we have any real estate needs. Nancy Neff